Home Coffee Makers The Ultimate Guide to the Best 4 Cup Coffee Makers: Features, Comparison, and Reviews

The Ultimate Guide to the Best 4 Cup Coffee Makers: Features, Comparison, and Reviews

The Ultimate Guide to the Best 4 Cup Coffee Makers: Features, Comparison, and Reviews

You might be interested in the best 4 cup coffee makers for different reasons. If you are single, live with someone who is not a coffee drinker, or simply do not wish to go overboard on caffeine, you may find yourself draining half a pot of coffee with every brew.

Perhaps, you have limited storage or counter space in your kitchen and want to make room for other essential appliances. In such cases, a regular 12-cup coffee maker might be more of a hassle than a convenience.

What should you do, then?

Well, this is exactly where a 4 Cup Coffee Maker comes in!

These compact machines are perfect for preventing clutter and waste while still giving you your daily cup. Additionally, they serve as an excellent means for small households or those who want a quick morning cup without brewing a whole pot.

So, whether you are tired of letting all that extra coffee go to waste or are looking to cut down on your expenses, our list of the best 4 Cup Coffee Makers will surely help you find one such unit that conforms to your needs.

Are you ready to have the full experience of a fresh brew without worrying about wastage?

If yes, then without further ado, let’s dig into the list of our five best 4 cup coffee makers.

The Five Best 4 Cup Coffee Makers

Okay, so we have done enough talking about why 4 cup coffee makers are a good choice and why people buy them.

Let’s get down to business and look at the best 4 cup coffee maker models that are bound to make your morning coffee routine easy-breezy.

We have reviewed each model carefully and have stacked up their features to make the selection as straightforward as possible.

And in case you do not find something of your liking (which is highly unlikely), there is also a buyer’s guide to let you know all ins and outs of making an informed decision.

1. Gevi 4 Cup Coffee Maker

4 cup coffee makers

The Gevi 4 cup Coffee Maker is one of the no-frill home brewers in the bunch that has all the necessary features of a good coffee maker without being overly complicated.

You will love the simple operation that Gevi provides. It has one-touch execution, meaning it only takes a single button to start brewing. This makes it a go-to choice for those with busy morning schedules when you do not have the time for fancy systems with the time-taking operation.

The keep-warm function and auto-pause feature are just as convenient and come in handy. Can’t finish the entire pot immediately? No problem! Turn on the keep warm function and keep your coffee hot for up to two hours. After that, the machine will automatically shut off to conserve power.

Another great addition to this 4 cup coffee maker is its reusable filter, which is something you rarely get with small-sized brewers. Constantly buying paper filters is terrible for both the environment and the wallet.

Still, Gevi’s reusable mesh filter works as effectively as the paper alternatives, and since it is dishwasher-safe, cleaning it is a breeze. That said, we must admit it is a little flimsy, so try not to press it too hard!

And did we mention Gevi’s boil-dry protection? It prevents boiling when insufficient water is in the reservoir, keeping your machine safe from getting damaged.

Standout Features

  • The auto pause and keep warm functions
  • Boil dry protection
  • Auto shutoff
  • Reusable filter


  • Highly compact option
  • One-touch brewing for hassle-free operation
  • Swing-out brew basket design for easy cleaning and loading


  • The mesh filter is a little flimsy
  • Some users complaint of a lingering plastic smell

2. Mr Coffee 4 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker

Mr. Coffee 4-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker

You can support us by making purchases from our links. We may earn commissions from it, at no additional cost to you.

The Mr Coffee coffee maker is one of the very few 4 cup coffee makers that is programmable and allows you to set up your brew ahead of time, ensuring that you wake up to the enticing aroma of coffee pot every morning.

It boasts a carefully-designed carafe made explicitly to retain the freshness of coffee and a cord storage compartment to keep your countertop neat and tidy. The Ounce markings on the machine’s carafe are another bonus that enables you to easily measure and see the amount of coffee in the reservoir.

4 cup coffee makers

And when it is time to brew, all you have to do is press one button, and you will have your java ready in no time. There is also an on/off indicator light to update you about the machine’s status and a two-hour shutoff that automatically turns it off in case you forget to.

However, some people felt that this two-hour shutoff was relatively short, while others disliked the efficiency of its permanent filter in filtering out the grounds from the coffee.

But except for these minor drawbacks, Mr Coffee’s 4 cup Programmable Coffee Maker is a solid option for those who value convenience and high quality when brewing coffee. Whether you want a single or double serving, this no-fuss brewer will deliver you the goods, time and again.

Standout Features

  • On/Off light indicator
  • Programmable for delayed brewing
  • Automatic shutoff
  • Grab-a-cup auto brew pause feature
  • Handy cord storage


  • One button execution
  • Visible ounce marking for accurate water filling
  • Removable filter basket for fast and easy cleaning
  • Keeps coffee hot for more prolonged periods


  • Slow brewing process
  • Some may find its 2-hour shutoff timer too short

3. Brentwood 4 Cup Coffee Maker

Brentwood 4 Cup Coffee Maker

You can support us by making purchases from our links. We may earn commissions from it, at no additional cost to you.

Even though the Brentwood 4 Cup Coffee Maker historically sells for less than its competitors, do not let it fool you into thinking it is any less. This budget-friendly option is fully functional and never fails to offer a gourmet and supreme cup of coffee.

You can get a home brewer for up to four cups at a time for a small price. This unit features a simple on/off switch and can heat up quickly, brewing your cup within minutes. Additionally, it includes a removable, lenient filter to use and clean; rinse it after every use, and it is ready for the next pot of coffee.

However, for a cleaner cup of coffee, we recommend using a paper filter; it effectively filters out the solids, saving you from all that grittiness and muddiness.

Another great feature of the Brentwood coffee maker is that it includes a warming plate that keeps your pot warm while you are still sipping on your first cup. Although it is not temperature controlled, we were happy with the maintained temperature it provided and reported a positive experience.

However, remember that this Brentwood machine has a larger footprint and takes up more space than its other four-cup competitors. And since it does not have an auto shuttle-off feature, you must also shut it off manually.

Regardless, this 4 cup coffee maker does an outstanding job brewing a warm cup of morning coffee and is a perfect pick for those looking for something basic and functional.

Standout Features

  • High-quality warming plate
  • Built-in water-level window
  • BPA-Free construction


  • Super affordable
  • Easy to use
  • The removable filter basket makes cleaning up a breeze
  • Available in many fun colors


  • No brew-pause or auto shutoff
  • Quite large and bulky

4. Cuisinart 4 Cup Coffeemaker

Cuisinart 4-Cup Coffeemaker

You can support us by making purchases from our links. We may earn commissions from it, at no additional cost to you.

Next, we have the Cuisinart DCC-450BK 4 cup Coffeemaker, another small reliable machine you can trust for your daily cup of hot coffee.

This small coffee maker model has a convenient brew pause-off functionality, allowing you to grab a cup anytime during brewing without making a mess. While it is always better to wait for the coffee pot to finish brewing to get equally extracted coffee, this function will be a lifesaver for those that are too much in a hurry to stay.

4 cup coffee makers

There is also a 30-minute automatic shutoff that turns off the unit after the allocated time so that you can rest assured knowing your coffee won’t burn.

The review is incomplete without mentioning Cuisinart’s unique carafe. Unlike a typical glass carafe on most coffee machines, this model boosts a different look with its stainless steel carafe. It looks great and keeps your coffee fresh and insulated, allowing you to enjoy it for extended periods without reheating it. The stainless steel construction also prevents issues with travel or shipping since it is more resistant to breakage than glass.

4 cup coffee makers

On the flip side, this unit by Cuisinart is prone to filter basket jams which not only makes the cleaning difficult but can also lead the coffee maker to back up and spill water everywhere.

Overall, the Cuisinart Coffee Maker is a strong contender in the 4 cup race that is sleek and shiny and entirely apt to brew barista-style coffee right from your kitchen.

Standout Features

  • Thermal carafe with knuckle guard
  • Pause and serve
  • 30-minute automatic shutoff


  • Perfectly suits small and crowded places
  • Dripless pour spout of the carafe to prevent any spillage
  • The hot plate is easy to clean


  • Prone to filter basket jams
  • Carafe can be hard to clean

5. Aigostar 4 Cups Drip Coffee Maker

Aigostar 4 Cups Drip Coffee Maker

You can support us by making purchases from our links. We may earn commissions from it, at no additional cost to you.

Last but not least, we have the Aigostar 4 cup coffee maker. While this brilliant little drip coffee maker certainly does not look like an average programmable brewer, it can provide some features that other models can’t.

One of our favorite features about this coffee machine is its warming plate. That is right; the Aigostar has a warming plate under its carafe that keeps your coffee warm for an extended duration. It lets you enjoy your java in several sittings, ensuring no coffee goes to waste.

The Aigostar coffee maker also includes a convenient anti-drip valve design, an essential feature of multi-cup coffee makers, that alleviates any concern regarding dripping when you take off the carafe.

Another massive pro of this brewing system is that it is powered by a strong 600-watt motor that accounts for the machine’s impressive 5-minute brewing time. At the same time, its 0.6-liter capacity water tank is more than enough to brew four 5-ounce cups at a time.

When you choose this 4 cup coffee maker, you can count on its removable coffee filter, which passes the coffee oils through, delivering a rich and full-bodied drink. In addition, the machine primarily consists of dishwasher-friendly parts that make its maintenance as effortless as its use.

To sum it up, the Aigostar coffee maker, with its high-power nature and user-friendly interface, is an excellent way to pour your cup with confidence.

Standout Features

  • Anti-drip valve design
  • On/Off switch with visible indicator light
  • Built-in non-stick insulation board inside the carafe
  • Powerful 500 Watts motor


  • It makes coffee super fast
  • Includes an easy-grip handle for comfortable pouring
  • It comes with a removable basket and cone filter for lenient use
  • Dishwasher-safe components for effortless cleaning


  • Brews slightly less volume
  • Somewhat noisy

How to Choose the Best 4 Cup Coffee Maker

Selecting the best 4 cup coffee maker is a difficult choice to make given the numerous products in the market, promising to be the best at their job. For this reason, it is essential to judge your desired coffee machine on various aspects to deduce how well and quickly it brews the coffee beans for you.

Here is a list of factors that can help determine the efficiency and suitability of any 4 cup coffee maker with your brewing style, technique, and equipment.

Brew Quality

Brew quality is deciding between passing or buying a particular coffee maker. Every coffee lover constantly seeks an acceptable, consistent, and high-brew-quality machine.

To unleash the authentic flavor of your beverage, we suggest you invest in a machine that uses the showerhead brewing method in contrast to the pulsing mechanism.

This is because the showerhead dispenser does a commendable job at spreading water over maximum grounds as opposed to the several dry spots left when using the spout method. In addition, you can also look for reliable certifications like the SCA that guarantee a high-quality, professional cup of Joe.


Are you also unable to start your day until you have had your daily cup of caffeine in the morning? If yes, you must know how frustrating it is to wait for your coffee to brew every morning. For this reason, you should always look for an appliance with a practical and fast heating element.

An ideal 4 cup coffee maker gets the water heated in no time and ensures it is of the precise temperature not to ruin the taste of your coffee and give it a bitter, burnt flavor. The quality of this heating element also improves or spoils the drink’s overall taste of the drink so make sure to make no compromises in terms of temperature control.

Ease of Use

No matter how fancy or advanced it seems, there is no point in investing in a machine that you struggle to use every day. Always look for a coffee maker with user-friendly controls such as an automatic shutoff, digital buttons, visible indicators, and easy-to-view and use water tanks.

Alongside this, since coffee makers are the type of appliances that need cleaning every day, we suggest you look for a simple to clean and maintain model. The best choice here is a coffee machine with dishwater-safe components, so there is one less chore every morning.

Build Quality

Last but not least, you need to consider the build size and quality of the chosen coffee maker. While all the products listed here have a 4 cup capacity, they vary in terms of shape, size, and quality. Since a coffee maker is a one-time investment, always stay away from cheap, plastic models that break down after a short time.

Instead, go with a stainless steel construction for optimal durability. Some people prefer to go with a glass carafe body because of its minimalist design and how well it pairs with various kitchen decor.

Editor’s Pick of Best 4 Cup Coffee Makers

The secret behind the best 4 cup small coffee maker lies in its user-friendly design, intelligent features, and excellent heat retention capabilities. You can find all of these features and much more in Mr Coffee’s 4 cup programmable coffee maker. This kitchen appliance is undoubtedly best at preparing the most mouth-watering cup of coffee without needing you to do much!

However, if you are looking for something that promises a decent flavor in a shorter span of time, you can look at the Aigostar drip coffee maker. This is another favorite of ours that outdoes all the other machines in terms of convenience, ease of use, and maintenance.

Whatever product you choose, make sure it is up to your desired mark and lets you have fun with your morning drink without too much hassle.

With that said, continue brewing and drinking your daily cup of Joe to prepare yourself for the hectic day!

This post may contain links that we earn a small commission from, at no cost to you, read more.